Urdu Poetry Forum

**Queen Victoria** · #1 03-23-2008, 10:01 AM

Assalamo o Allaikum
March 2008 kay contest kay liye share kiye gaye image yahan post kiye ja rahay hain.
Selected judges yahan in sab images ko 1-10 marks kay mutabiq rate karain gay.
Aap sab say guzarish hai kay siwaye judges kay koi yahan kisi qisam ki koi post na karay,
becaues ye thread sirf judges kay liye hai.
sab irrelevant posts delete kar di jain gi
Shukria
Good luck to all participents

Image 1

Image 2

Image 3

Image 4

**Queen Victoria** · #2 03-23-2008, 10:06 AM

rejected image
reason: HG official logo and URL are not there, mentioned as in rules.

**Banjara** · #3 03-23-2008, 12:44 PM

First of all I must say rejected image doesn't even fall under category of "Senior Designers Work", sorry for a straight comments, but couldn't stop saying this.

now I must say the more happy I was with work I seen by junior designers, even more disappointed I am with most of work shared here. Anyways I come to comments and rating straight away.

1: rating 5/10 - a very nice border but why such a big background ? and word style is not very good either. what's wrong ? It looks like this image was made in rush and not even for competition, I can say this because I have seen some very good images designed by yourself.

2: rating 6/10 - very cool border, but what happened to background and word styles ? Didn't you find a good concept for the background ? and what is that on top left and bottom right corner ? you could have used nothing then this.

3: rating 8/10 - this is what i can say an image designed by a senior designer, a very good composition, and formation of things, good color combination, good border, very good image.

4: rating 7/10 - a good image but what happen to color scheme ? border doesn't go well with left side of the image but okay with right side of the image, 2ndly what happen to word style ? 2ndly the movement you have in left background image it over running rest of the image including border and font style etc.,

Overall I am disappointed with most of the images in this competition of Senior designers, I have very high expectations from you.

Regards,

**Kinza...!** · #4 03-24-2008, 06:26 AM

Image 1: 6/10
Image 2: 7/10
for original frame I gave u 1 xtra point
Image 3:9/10
Beautiful image
Image 4: 7/10
Cs mujhe lag raha hai as seniors hame khud bht choti choti chizon par bht paband hona parega aapke is image me girl ki back pe side me sirf 3 steps arahe hain kamar ke paas jo baal hain wahan dekhye uuse clone hona chaye tha
ispe me negative marking kerna chah rahi thi lekin chunke MOD ne is image pe rule ke mutabiq koyi comment nahi dia to me confuse hogayi hun ke kahin rules me narmi hogayi ho aur mujhe ilm na ho

**aawara** · #5 03-24-2008, 12:25 PM

Img 1: 5/10
Only border work is good. Txt is ok. BG is far way from ur standard. Really disappointed from ur work.

Img 2: 6.5/10
Border work is awesome. Txt work is good according to the bg. But Zia bhai if u would post this image in POD then everyone would say its a good image. But for a compettion u have to show something extraordinary. It looks like u cant develop a theme for this Nazam.

Img 3: 9/10
Beautiful...A perfectly balanced image.

Img 4: 7/10
Overall good image. The image needs cloning. Title is mixing in the bg.

**mystique** · #6 03-24-2008, 04:45 PM

Image # 1...6/10

Image # 2...7/10

Image # 3...10/10

Image # 4...8/10

**Queen Victoria** · #7 03-24-2008, 05:42 PM

Image 1...7/10

Image 2...8.1/10

Image 3...9/10

Image 4...8.3/10

Urdu Poetry Forum

Vote 4 Best Senior Designer Of The Month, March 2008

Vote 4 Best Senior Designer Of The Month, March 2008