Quote:
Originally Posted by Mukhshif  yaani Rasool Allah salallaho alayhe wasalam ki 72 Ahadees ke muqablay mai Ibn Hajar ki kahi gayi eik baat ki ehmiyat ziyada samjhi jaye? |
aap ki is baat pe dil kerta he k aik noha likhon ... dil ko rohon ya piton jigar ko mein...yaani jo baat ki lajawab ki. Ibn e hajar ki tanqeed hadith ki authenticity per he. itna to aap k ilm mein hoga k hadith se istambat kerne se pehle us ko perkha jata he, pir us hadith ko apne istadlaal ki buneyad banaya jata he. Zara socheye k Mufti shafi sahab ko ye zarurat keon peysh aai k un rawayaat k hawale se Ibn e hajar ki raye per tanqeed kerte...is leye bhaii sahab k is k baghyr wo un rawayaat ko daleel nahein bana sakte the. aor unhon ne to khud bohat se rawayaat k bare mein aehtaraf kia he k ye mohaddeseen k nazdeek zaheef hein.
is leye bhaii sahab ulama ki baton per aankhein band ker k nahein gir perte, kuch apni aqal bhi istemaal kerna chaheye, wo bhi allah hi ki ata kerta nehmat he.