Quote:
Originally Posted by Mukhshif  Asalam-o-Alaikum
mujhe jahan tak yaad hai, yeh baat pehle sochi bhi nahi ja sakti thi, eik musalman ki hesiyat se hum yeh baat achi terhaan jantay or samjhtay thay ke mousiqi haram hai, or sirf daff ki ijazat hai, woh bhi shadi ke mouqay per lerkio ko, ab dor-e-jadeed ke fitno mai eik fitna yeh bhi hai ke mosiqi ko ain islami qarar dene ki koshish ho rahi hai, or yeh fitna sarasar "Munkereen-e-Hadees" ki janib se berpa kiye gaye fitno mai se eik hai..... mai irfan bhai ka shukria ada kerta hoon ke unho ne eik umda tehreer share ki thi JazakAllah Irfan bhai |
mein bhi yahi samaghti hoon hem fitnoon ke door mein rah rahe hein, so yeh jawaaz keh aisa pehle socha bhi nahi ja sakta tha kissi aamer ko memnoon qaraar deine ke liye kafi nahi, yeh to yahood o nasara walli baat lagti he hem ne appne baap dada ko kerte neh sunna na daikha so iss liye neh manne gein. kal ka bachcha shayyed yeh bhi pooche keh Islam mein zana ki ijjazet he keh nahi, aur kiss bunaid peh. So ager hame her masle mein bunaid maloom ho to fitnoon se bachchna mumkin he. Aur her uthne walle sawaal ko khushamdeed kehne ki zarooret neh keh yeh kaha jaye keh yeh aik aur fitna he so iss sawal ko hi neh uthne do.
Irfan ki kawish achchi he mager iss thread mein jo ahadees paish ki gayee hein unn mein do mutazaad batein samne ayeen hein kuch mein ganne bajanne ko bohut bura paish kia gia he aur kuch mein qabool kia gia he.